12 Reasons Students Struggle in College – And What to Do When They Come Home

They graduated from high school. They got into college. Everyone was excited. And then, somewhere along the way, it stopped working. Maybe they started missing class, or they never really found their people. Maybe anxiety took over, marijuana became an everyday habit, or they simply stopped caring about coursework that felt meaningless. Soon enough, they were back home.

At Rooted Life Adventures, we work with a lot of young adults in exactly this position.

Some barely made it through high school - with parents, teachers, tutors, counselors, accommodations, and a whole lot of structure helping them across the finish line. Then they arrived at college and suddenly all of that support disappeared. Others worked incredibly hard to get through high school but arrived at college already burnt out. After years of pushing themselves just to keep up, the thought of doing four more years felt impossible. And for others, college was simply the first time the skills they hadn't developed yet became impossible to ignore.

Usually, there isn't one dramatic reason college didn't work. It's several small things that start stacking on top of each other.

Here are 12 of the most common patterns we see.

1. They couldn't manage their own schedule.

In high school, structure is largely created for you. School starts at the same time every morning. Teachers notice when you're missing. Parents wake you up. Coaches expect you at practice. Dinner happens. Homework gets checked. Someone usually knows where you're supposed to be. College can remove almost all of that overnight.

Suddenly, a student might have a class at 10:00 a.m., nothing until 3:00 p.m., and no one checking whether they attend either one. They have a paper due in three weeks - but no one is telling them what they should be doing this Tuesday to make sure it gets finished. They have four classes with four different syllabi, deadlines scattered throughout the semester, appointments to remember, assignments to prioritize, and enormous chunks of unscheduled time.

For a student who hasn't learned how to create structure for themselves, that freedom can quickly become chaos.

2. One missed class turned into five.

We see this particularly often with students who have ADHD or struggle with executive functioning. They miss one class and now they're behind. Being behind feels overwhelming, so they avoid looking at the assignment. Then they miss another class because they haven't done the assignment and now walking back into class feels embarrassing - so they avoid it again. What began as one missed Tuesday can become weeks of avoidance, and the further behind they get, the harder it feels to ask for help.

Eventually, the problem isn't intelligence or academic ability at all. It's that they don't know how to interrupt the avoidance cycle and recover when things start going wrong.

3. They never found their people.

College is often sold as an instant social experience: roommates, football games, clubs, parties, lifelong friends. That isn't everyone's experience. Some students struggle to take the first step socially, they don't join the club or knock on someone's door. They eat alone instead of asking someone to dinner. A few lonely weeks can turn into a lonely semester and when you don't feel connected to anyone, there are fewer reasons to leave your room.

4. Their world got very small - and very online.

This often goes hand-in-hand with loneliness. There are suddenly enormous stretches of unstructured time, and screens are an incredibly easy way to fill them. Gaming. TikTok. YouTube. Discord. Netflix. There is nothing inherently wrong with any of those things, the problem is when an online world gradually replaces the real one. Sleep gets later, classes get missed, meals become irregular and social opportunities disappear.

Eventually, a student can technically be living on a college campus while barely participating in college life at all.

5. The academic jump was bigger than they expected.

For some students, college isn't the first time academics have been hard. High school was hard, too. The difference is that in high school there may have been a lot of people helping them keep it together. Parents reminded them about assignments, teachers offered extensions, tutors helped them catch up, counselors checked in. Maybe they had accommodations or an IEP. Someone noticed when things started slipping. Some students barely made it through high school even with all of that support.

Others succeeded - but at an enormous personal cost. They spent four years stressed, exhausted, anxious, or constantly trying to catch up. They graduated already burnt out, and then college starts. The reading increases and Professors expect more independence. There may be fewer assignments, but each one matters more. Nobody necessarily notices that you haven't started the paper that's due next week. For a student who was already struggling academically - or exhausted from years of trying not to struggle - the jump can simply be too much.

6. They didn't have the life skills to manage life on their own.

College readiness isn't just about academics. Can you do your laundry before you run out of clothes? Keep your room reasonably clean? Figure out meals and groceries? Make your own doctor's appointment? Order the books you need for class? Read a syllabus and put the important dates somewhere you'll actually remember them? Realize you're struggling in a class, email the professor, and make an appointment to talk about it? Plan your week? Look at a deadline three weeks away and work backwards to figure out what needs to happen this week?

These things sound small, but adulthood is largely made up of small things. When twenty of them pile up at once, a young adult who hasn't practiced managing them can become completely overwhelmed. The solution isn't necessarily for Mom or Dad to swoop back in and manage everything again. Students need opportunities to actually practice doing these things themselves - with enough support that mistakes become learning experiences rather than catastrophes

7. Substance use started taking up too much space.

This is one families don't always see immediately. Sometimes a student falls into a social group where drinking or marijuana use becomes the primary activity. Other times, substance use begins because there isn't much else happening. They're lonely, stressed, disappointed in themselves and skipping class. They have hours to fill. Getting high makes those hours easier. The problem is that it can also make it easier to continue avoiding everything that isn't going well. What started as something social can become part of a much bigger cycle of isolation, avoidance and disengagement.

8. Depression made everything harder.

Sometimes the student isn't being lazy. Getting out of bed genuinely feels hard and going to class feels hard. Showering feels hard, responding to texts feels hard and meeting new people feels impossible.

And unfortunately, many of the things that could help - routine, movement, community, purpose, getting outside - are exactly the things that become harder to do when someone is struggling with depression. The result can become a self-reinforcing cycle of isolation.

9. Anxiety - or perfectionism - made starting feel impossible.

College provides endless opportunities to feel uncertain. Am I smart enough? Do these people like me? What if I fail this class, or I chose the wrong major? What am I doing with my life? For some young adults, anxiety leads to avoidance. And for others, it shows up as perfectionism.

Is this paper good enough? What if I do it wrong? What if I turn it in and get a bad grade? A paper doesn't feel ready unless it's perfect. And if they don't believe they can make it perfect, they can't make themselves start. Or they write it - and can't make themselves submit it. It can look completely irrational from the outside: just turn in the paper. But when perfectionism and anxiety are driving the behavior, turning in something that feels imperfect can feel worse than turning in nothing at all.

So they don't, and then they're behind. Now they're ashamed that they're behind and avoidance becomes the escape hatch. Skip the class, don't check the grade, don't respond to the professor, stay in the room and go home for the weekend. Eventually, leaving college itself can begin to feel like the only way to make the anxiety stop.

10. They had no idea why they were there.

This one matters enormously. A lot of 18-year-olds go to college because that's simply what comes after high school. But ask:

Why are you studying this?

What are you hoping to build?

What kind of life interests you?

And the answer is:

I don't know.

That doesn't mean they need their entire life mapped out at 18, but it's difficult to push through something challenging when you don't see any reason for doing it. Without some sense of purpose or direction, college can begin to feel like an incredibly expensive exercise in completing assignments. Students aren't moving toward something they chose, they're just doing what they think they're supposed to do.

11. It was simply the wrong school.

Sometimes there isn't anything deeper going on. The university has 40,000 students and they need something smaller or the college is tiny and they feel trapped. They chose a school for its ranking instead of its culture. Perhaps they wanted city life and ended up in a college town - or thought they wanted a huge campus and discovered they desperately missed community. Sometimes the vibe is just wrong. Finding the wrong fit doesn't mean someone isn't capable of succeeding in college, it may simply mean they chose the wrong college.

12. Usually, it's several of these things at once.

This may be the most important point. A student doesn't find friends, so they spend more time in their room and they start staying up until 3:00 a.m. gaming. Then they miss their 9:00 a.m. class, and they're embarrassed about being behind, so they stop going. Their grades drop, they start smoking marijuana more often because they're stressed and now they're even less motivated. Their anxiety increases. They stop answering their parents' questions because every conversation feels like another reminder that they're failing. And eventually: “I want to come home.”

There wasn't one problem, there was a cascade.

And Then They Come Home

This is the part that doesn't get talked about enough. For many young adults, leaving college isn't just a change of plans - it can absolutely crush their confidence. They watched their friends stay and see everyone else's college photos on Instagram. Their parents might have spent money and people keep asking, “How's school?" Internally, they may be thinking they failed. We've talked to families whose daughter came home from college and barely wanted to leave the house, not because she didn't want a life, but because she was terrified she'd run into someone at the grocery store. What if she saw one of her old classmates' parents or if someone asked where she was going to school? What if they asked the dreaded question: “Why aren't you in college?” All of her friends were away at school and she was back in her childhood bedroom. She felt like everyone else was moving forward and she was the disappointment who had come home.

She desperately needed to get out of the house, but she was almost afraid to leave it. And frankly, that's a pretty good reason to get on a flight to Australia. Not to run away from what happened, but to go do something next. Something big enough to change the story she's telling herself about who she is.

They May Need a Break. But It Should Be a Productive One.

There is an important distinction between taking time off and using time intentionally. For some young adults, the answer isn't immediately returning to college, but isn't necessarily a therapeutic program, either. It probably isn't ten weeks of partying, backpacking and tourism as a reward for dropping out. They likely need something more purposeful than that - an experience that asks something of them. Something that rebuilds confidence through action, where they have responsibilities and have to get out of bed. Where other people are counting on them and they live with peers instead of retreating into a bedroom. A place where they cook dinner, do their laundry, manage their schedule, navigate conflict, show up for work, make appointments, meet deadlines, try unfamiliar things and discover that they can actually do these things. They need some adventure, too - they should surf, hike, travel, laugh, meet people and have an incredible experience. But underneath the adventure, something more important should be happening - they should be practicing life.

The Goal Isn't to “Fix” Them. It's to Prepare Them.

A young adult who leaves college doesn't need to spend the next year feeling like a failure. College gave them information. Maybe they discovered that they need better executive-functioning skills, or to better understand how ADHD affects them. They might need stronger coping strategies or they need to practice building friendships. Maybe they need to learn how to create structure without their parents creating it for them or desperately need to learn basic independent-living skill. They might like to reconsider their major or explore the option of a completely different school.

They could need further real-world experience to figure out what they actually want their education to be for. That's all valuable information - if they do something with it.

That's Where a Supported Gap Year Can Be Different

At Rooted Life Adventures, we think there's a huge space between “go back to college and try harder” and “you need treatment.” We call that space a Supported Gap Year.

Our students live together in a house rather than moving from hostel to hostel. They have real responsibilities that include cooking and cleaning. They volunteer and participate in internships. Our students travel and adventure, have structured activities every day and free time in which they gradually learn to manage themselves.

And alongside the group is a dedicated Wellness Coach - a licensed therapist who isn't there to provide clinical therapy, but to help students navigate real life while they're actually living it. The support is there when they need it and it steps back when they don't.

Because ultimately, the goal isn't to create a young adult who succeeds because someone is managing their life for them, the goal is to help them become someone who knows how to manage their own.

College Not Working the First Time Doesn't Have to Be the End of the Story

Sometimes an unsuccessful first attempt at college is exactly that, a first attempt. The next chapter doesn't have to be about failure - it can be about figuring out what didn't go right, building the skills that were missing, rediscovering confidence and deciding - with much more intention - what comes next.

Maybe that's returning to the same university or transferring. It could be community college or vocational training or entering the workforce. It could be an entirely different direction. The outcome doesn't need to be predetermined, but whatever comes next, we want young adults walking toward it because they've chosen it. Not because it's simply what they're “supposed” to do.

More capable, confident and connected. And much more ready for whatever comes next.

This blog post was written by Austin Rogers, the Founder and Owner of Rooted Life Adventures. Read more from Austin here, or check out her bio.

12 Reasons Students Struggle in College – And What to Do When They Come Home
My Teen Struggled Through High School. What Comes Next?
Best Gap Year Programs for Students With ADHD: What Parents Should Look For

© 2025 Rooted Life Adventures Ltd. All Rights Reserved